The BEST Deep Fried Turkey Recipe Using Peanut Oil (2024)

This amazing deep fried turkey recipe is what turned me from a turkey hater to a TURKEY LOVER… My fried turkey turns out tender, juicy, and flavorful EVERY TIME (thanks to a simple fried turkey rub + peanut oil). AND the cooking time is trimmed to under an hour by using an electric indoor turkey fryer!

The Best Deep Fried Turkey Recipe

I have a confession to make… I’ve never really been a fan of turkey. Shocking, huh?! In fact, there have been many years when I’ve opted to make a spiral ham for Thanksgiving dinner instead.

BUT I have a husband and three boys that all happen to love turkey. So several years ago I decided to try frying a turkey.

And you know what? It was kinda life changing! I’d never eaten turkey that wasn’t dry and flavorless, so I feel obligated to share my discovery with the world.

This deep fried turkey recipe produces a perfectly deep-fried turkey with golden brown, crispy skin. We’re talking a Thanksgiving turkey with meat that’s tender, juicy, and flavorful EVERY TIME!!

Meanwhile, I have way more room in the oven for our favorite Thanksgiving side dishes. AND the cooking time is trimmed to under an hour! #winning

I know, I know — we’ve all heard the horror stories about propane tank turkey fryers and scary grease fires. Many of these situations happen because of simple user error, like adding too much oil. Or poor decisions, like placing the fryer on a wooden deck.

But don’t worry! I’ve got a far better solution…

Frying Turkey In An Indoor Turkey Deep Fryer

Did you know that you can actually purchase an electric indoor turkey fryer?!? Yep, and they’re MUCH safer to use. So safe that you can fry a whole turkey right on your kitchen countertop!! Of course, it’s always a good idea to have a fire extinguisher on hand for emergencies.

My original Butterball electric fryer (pictured above) is no longer sold. But there are two newer versions: one that can deep-fry turkey up to 12 pounds and one that fries turkeys up to 20 pounds.

I upgraded to the larger model a few years ago, and it’s the one I would recommend for most households. Finding 12-lb. and under turkeys can be a bit difficult, and the price difference is negligible!

Not to mention they’re useful for more than frying whole turkeys! You can fry almost anything in your electric turkey fryer… Use it for frying fish, chicken wings, French fries, or even donuts. And it also has a steaming feature, making it much more versatile than at first glance.

Key Ingredients For A Perfect Deep-Fried Turkey

Deep-frying turkey produces the most juicy turkey you will ever eat. But the trifecta of juicy meat, crispy skin, and loads of flavor requires more than just dropping a turkey in a couple gallons of hot oil…

Two elements take this deep-fried turkey recipe to the next level — my homemade seasoning for turkey and my choice of fry oil!

The Turkey Seasoning

The turkey rub recipe is super simple to throw together. It’s ideal for seasoning the turkey both inside AND out, which is key for creating loads of flavor!

The best part? This turkey seasoning recipe goes BIG on flavor with only 4 ingredients:

• poultry seasoning
• garlic powder
• salt
• ground black pepper

Around here, prepping for Thanksgiving starts well before the big day. So even though it’s a minimal timesaver, one thing I always do early in the week is mix up my deep fried turkey rub.

Whisk the spice rub ingredients together in a small bowl. Then transfer the turkey dry rub to an airtight container. Store it with the rest of your spices until you’re ready to season and fry your turkey.

The Turkey Fryer Oil

Any common cooking oil can be used to deep fry turkey. But if you want the best-tasting fried bird, there’s a clear winner in this category. My preferred turkey fryer oil is peanut oil for its rich flavor and high smoke point. In my opinion, it’s simply the best oil to fry turkey.

The downside? Well, peanut oil doesn’t come cheap! And you’re gonna need about 2.5 gallons of oil to fill up the large turkey fryer…

PRO TIP: Save the original peanut oil container after filling your turkey fryer pot. When you’ve finished deep frying your turkey, allow the peanut oil to cool completely. Then filter the cooled oil through a fine-mesh strainer lined with cheesecloth back into the bottle. By doing this, you can reuse it several more times!

How To Prepare A Turkey For Deep Frying

Using an electric turkey fryer to make deep fried turkey is an easy and mostly hands off method. To achieve the best results, it’s important to prepare the turkey well!

You CAN season and fry the turkey the same day. But for the most flavorful turkey, I recommend following these steps the day before you plan to deep fry.

1. Start with a fully thawed turkey: I cannot stress how important this is! Oil and water don’t mix, and neither do oil and ice. Depending on the size, a frozen turkey can take 4-5 days to thaw in the refrigerator. So be sure to move it early in the week to ensure it’s completely defrosted.
2. Rinse and dry: Remove the neck and giblets, as well as any plastic leg ties and/or the pop-up cooking indicator. Rinse the thawed bird with cold water inside and out, then set the turkey on a wire rack set on a rimmed baking sheet. Pat it completely dry inside and out. If you’re using a fresh turkey, you can obviously skip the thawing part and proceed right to the rinsing step.
3. Trim the excess bits: Using a pair of sturdy poultry shears, trim any excess skin and fat from around the neck area. This will ensure that the hot peanut oil can easily fill the inside of the turkey.
4. Season turkey inside and out: Rub the seasoning into the turkey’s skin. Then sprinkle the remainder inside the body cavity.

Place the turkey in the refrigerator uncovered for 12-24 hours to allow the spices to infuse the meat.

How To Fry A Turkey In Peanut Oil

When you’re ready to fry your turkey, remove the turkey from the refrigerator. This will allow it to start to come to room temperature while the oil is heating up.

Fill the turkey fryer pot up to the maximum fill line with peanut oil. Then switch the fryer on, and heat the oil to 375 degrees. When the oil temperature reaches 375 degrees, transfer the prepared turkey to the fryer basket.

Wearing a pair of silicone mitts, very slowly lower turkey into the oil. Make sure it’s fully submerged and that the oil has filled the cavity. Sometimes the turkey will need to “burp” to get it to fill with oil. It’s handy to have a pair of rubber-tipped tongs that you can use to to gently nudge and tilt it until you’re sure it’s filled.

Calculate The Turkey Frying Time

You can determine how long to fry a turkey by multiplying the weight of the turkey in pounds by 3.5-4 minutes per pound. So if you have a 14 pound turkey, you should fry it for approximately 49-56 minutes. If you’re wondering how long do you deep fry a 20lb turkey, you’ll want to leave it in for 70-80 minutes. See the printable chart above for a quick estimate.

Fried turkey internal temperature

The easiest way to tell if your turkey is cooked through is by inserting a meat thermometer into the thickest part of the breast. The recommended turkey internal temperature is 165 degrees.

When the turkey reaches the recommended temperature, put your silicone gloves back on. Carefully lift the fryer basket out of the oil, allowing the excess oil to drip back into the fryer.

Clip the basket on the draining holes to drip and rest in the basket for about 10 minutes. Then transfer the turkey to a platter lined with paper towels for an additional 10 minutes or so to soak up any excess oil.

Once the turkey is cool enough to handle, you can carve and serve it! I highly recommend using an electric knife for carving. It makes cutting precise slices effortless.

Safety Tips For Deep Frying Turkey

Using an indoor turkey fryer is far safer than an outdoor model. But you’ll still want to follow a few safety precautions when deep frying turkey.

A few we’ve already covered, such as making sure your turkey is completely thawed. Also, always use silicone gloves to protect your hands. And take care to go very slowly when lowering and lifting the turkey.

My family thinks this is literally the BEST deep fried turkey recipe… They may be a little biased, but I hope yours enjoys it as much as mine!

If you’re curious what we serve alongside it, I’ve listed out my exact Thanksgiving menu. Or keep scrolling after the printable recipe for some of our favorite easy sides.

The BEST Deep Fried Turkey Recipe

Yield: 16 servings

Prep Time: 30 minutes

Cook Time: 52 minutes

Additional Time: 30 minutes

Total Time: 1 hour 52 minutes

An amazing deep fried turkey recipe that turned me from a turkey hater to a TURKEY LOVER... This deep fried turkey turns out tender, juicy, and flavorful EVERY TIME (thanks to an easy fried turkey rub + peanut oil). AND the cooking time is trimmed to under an hour by using an electric turkey fryer!

Ingredients

for the fried turkey rub:

• 2 tablespoons poultry seasoning
• 1/2 tablespoon garlic powder
• 1 tablespoon salt
• 1/2 tablespoon ground black pepper

for the fried turkey:

• 1 (13-14 lbs.) thawed whole turkey, neck and giblets discarded
• 2 gallons peanut oil

Instructions

Prepare The Fried Turkey Rub

1. Whisk together the poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and black pepper in a small bowl.
2. Set the turkey seasoning aside while you prepare the turkey for frying.

How To Prepare A Turkey For Deep Frying

1. Rinse a fully thawed turkey inside and out with cold water, then allow all of the water to drain out. Place the turkey on a wire rack set on a rimmed baking sheet. Thoroughly pat the turkey dry inside and out with paper towels. If your turkey has plastic leg ties and/or a pop-up cooking indicator, be sure to remove them before frying!
2. Using a pair of sturdy poultry shears, trim any excess skin and fat from around the neck area. This will ensure that the hot peanut oil can easily fill the inside of the turkey.
3. Rub the turkey all over with the deep fried turkey rub, including the inside.
4. You can fry the turkey immediately, if desired. However, I recommend placing the turkey uncovered in the refrigerator for 12-24 hours to allow the spices to infuse the meat.

How To Make A Juicy Deep Fried Turkey

1. Fill the fryer pot up to the maximum fill line with peanut oil. Remove your prepared turkey from the refrigerator to allow it to start to come to room temperature while they oil is heating up. Turn your electric turkey fryer on, and heat the peanut oil to 375 degrees.
2. When the temperature of the oil reaches 375 degrees, place turkey in the included basket. Very slowly lower the turkey into the hot oil, making sure to submerge it completely, and close the lid. I recommend wearing protective silicone gloves for this step. It’s also handy to have a pair ofrubber-tipped tongsto gently nudge and tilt the turkey to make sure it’s filled with the peanut oil.
3. Calculate your cook time and set a timer. How long to fry a turkey is determined by multiplying the weight of your turkey in pounds by 3.5-4 minutes of cook time per pound. For example: if your turkey weighs 14lbs, you would cook it for approximately 49-56 minutes. You can be sure the turkey is fully cooked when an instant-read thermometer inserted in the thickest part of the breast reads at least 165 degrees.
4. When the turkey reaches the recommended internal temperature of 165 degrees, carefully lift the fryer basket out of the oil, allowing the excess oil to drip back into the fryer.
5. Clip the basket on the draining holes to drip and rest in the basket for about 10 minutes. Then transfer it to a platter lined with paper towels for an additional 10 minutes or so to soak up any excess oil.
6. Once the turkey is cool enough to handle, you can carve and serve it. I recommend using an electric knife for carving, which easily makes precise slices.

Notes

How To Cook A Deep Fried Turkey Breast

You can also deep fry a turkey breast in your electric turkey fryer! Follow the directions above to season the turkey breast. Turn on the turkey fryer, and preheat the peanut oil to 375 degrees. Situate the prepared turkey breast in the frying basket, and very lowly lower it into the hot oil. Once the turkey breast is submerged, lower the fryer temperature to 325 degrees. Cook for approximately 7 minutes per pound, until a meat thermometer inserted in the breast reads at least 165 degrees.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon.com Services LLC Associates and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

• 

  McCormick Poultry Seasoning

• 

  Masterbuilt Stainless Steel Turkey Deep Fryer

• 

  Lavatools Instant Read Thermometer

• 

  OXO Good Grips 12-Inch Tongs

• 

  Gorilla Grip Silicone Oven Mitts

• 

  Hamilton Beach Electric Carving Knife

Nutrition Information:

Yield: 16
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 603Total Fat: 33.6gSaturated Fat: 9gCholesterol: 228mgSodium: 571mgCarbohydrates: 1.5gFiber: .3gSugar: 0gProtein: 68.8g

Have you tried this recipe?

Leave a comment below and share a photo on Instagram. Tag it @unsophisticook and hashtag it #unsophisticook!